The Best Bird Feeders for Every Type of Bird (And How to Choose)

Feeding birds isn’t just about tossing out some seed and hoping for the best. Different species have different eating styles, body shapes, and preferences—and if you match the feeder to the bird, you’ll have a much more active, diverse, and healthier backyard bird population.

Let’s take a deeper look at each type of feeder, what birds they’re best suited for, the pros and cons, and how to choose the right one for your yard.

---

🐦 1. Tube Feeders

Best for: Chickadees, finches, titmice, nuthatches, pine siskins

Tube feeders are tall, narrow cylinders with multiple small perches and feeding ports. They’re great for small birds that are comfortable perching and picking seed with precision.

✅ Why they work:

• Birds like chickadees and finches prefer to cling and peck at a seed opening.

• Ports help minimize seed waste and prevent overcrowding.

• Ideal for keeping larger birds and squirrels out—especially when paired with a cage or baffle.

⚠️ Watch out for:

• Smaller ports may clog with seed blends that contain cracked corn or large chunks.

• Can get moldy at the bottom if not cleaned regularly.

Pro Tip: Use black-oil sunflower or nyjer seed. Fill only halfway in rainy seasons to avoid waste.

Recommended Feeders:
🛒 Droll Yankees Classic Tube Feeder:

---

🐦 2. Platform (Tray) Feeders

Best for: Cardinals, blue jays, mourning doves, juncos, sparrows

Platform feeders are simple, open trays that can be mounted, hung, or placed on the ground. They offer the most “natural” feeding experience for ground-feeding and larger birds who can’t use small perches.

✅ Why they work:

• Allows multiple birds to feed at once with plenty of space.

• Great visibility and accessibility for shy birds like cardinals.

• Can accommodate a wide variety of food types—seed, fruit, mealworms, nuts.

⚠️ Watch out for:

• Exposed to weather, which can spoil food faster.

• Easily accessed by squirrels and even raccoons if not protected.

• Needs frequent cleaning due to droppings.

Pro Tip: Sprinkle safflower seed to attract cardinals and deter squirrels—it’s one of the few seeds they’ll ignore.

Recommended Feeders:
🛒 Woodlink Hanging Platform Feeder:

---

🐦 3. Suet Feeders

Best for: Woodpeckers, wrens, nuthatches, chickadees

Suet feeders are usually simple cages that hold blocks of suet—a high-fat, high-protein food birds love, especially in colder months when energy demands are high.

✅ Why they work:

• Appeals to insect-eating birds, who appreciate a substitute when bugs are scarce.

• Easy to hang from branches or poles.

• Can attract birds that might not come to seed feeders.

⚠️ Watch out for:

• Suet melts in hot weather—look for “no-melt” blends for summer use.

• Can attract starlings or grackles unless you use upside-down feeders (which woodpeckers prefer).

Pro Tip: Hang it near a tree trunk or post to mimic natural foraging habits of clingers like woodpeckers.

Recommended Feeders:
🛒 Tail Prop Suet Feeder:

🐦 4. Hopper Feeders

Best for: Cardinals, grosbeaks, sparrows, finches, jays

Hopper feeders look like little birdhouses with seed storage inside. Seed flows down as birds eat, and a small roof helps keep it dry.

✅ Why they work:

• Holds a large amount of seed—great for fewer refills.

• Provides shelter from rain and snow, keeping food fresh longer.

• Works well for both small and medium-sized birds.

⚠️ Watch out for:

• Can be hard to clean if seed gets damp or moldy.

• Attracts squirrels easily if not protected.

• The interior can harbor bacteria—scrub regularly with a vinegar-water mix.

Pro Tip: Mount hopper feeders on a pole with a squirrel baffle for best results. Use high-quality blends to avoid filler mess.

Recommended Feeders:
🛒 Perky-Pet Squirrel-Be-Gone Feeder:

---

🐦 5. Nyjer (Thistle) Feeders

Best for: American goldfinches, pine siskins, redpolls

Nyjer feeders are built specifically for tiny seeds and tiny beaks. The seed is high in oil and a favorite for finches.

✅ Why they work:

• Tiny feeding ports prevent waste.

• Limits access to small-billed birds only.

• Attracts bright yellow goldfinches in flocks when conditions are right.

⚠️ Watch out for:

• Nyjer spoils quickly if it gets wet—replace every couple of weeks.

• Seed is more expensive and can spill easily if feeder isn’t properly filled.

Pro Tip: Place nyjer feeders in a quieter part of your yard to encourage shy finches to feed in peace.

Recommended Feeders:
🛒 Kaytee Finch Feeder Sock:

---

🐦 6. Peanut Feeders

Best for: Blue jays, woodpeckers, titmice, chickadees

Peanut feeders use mesh designs to hold shelled or unshelled peanuts, offering a high-protein snack for bigger, more assertive birds.

✅ Why they work:

• Attracts species that might skip seed feeders altogether.

• Durable and long-lasting—mesh holds up in bad weather.

• Provides entertainment as birds work to pull nuts out.

⚠️ Watch out for:

• Squirrels love peanuts—use squirrel baffles or weight-sensitive hangers.

• Can get moldy quickly in humid weather if not checked.

Pro Tip: Use raw, unsalted peanuts to keep birds healthy. Avoid roasted or flavored nuts.

Recommended Feeders:
🛒 Peanut Wreath Feeder:

---

🛡️ Bonus: Squirrel-Proof Feeders

Best for: All seed-eating birds + your sanity

Squirrel-proof feeders use clever designs like spring-loaded perches or weight-sensitive covers that block squirrels without harming them.

✅ Why they work:

• Automatically shuts off access to heavier animals.

• Saves you money on wasted seed.

• Keeps birds stress-free while feeding.

⚠️ Watch out for:

• Some models are bulky or complex to clean.

• Cheap versions break easily or don’t actually work.

Pro Tip: Combine squirrel-proof feeders with pole-mounted baffles for total protection—and keep feeders 8–10 feet away from anything a squirrel can jump from.

Recommended Feeders:
🛒 Squirrel Buster Plus:

---

🔍 How to Choose the Right Bird Feeder

Choosing the right feeder depends on a few key things:

1. Who are you feeding?

Use apps like Merlin Bird ID or eBird to learn what species are in your area. Want finches? Get nyjer. Want cardinals? Choose trays or hoppers.

2. How much space do you have?

• Small yard: Go vertical with tube or suet feeders.

• Large yard: Use a feeder pole system to offer multiple styles.

3. Weather & maintenance

• Rainy/humid climates: Avoid open trays or choose mesh bottoms.

• Cold winters: Offer suet and heated bird baths.

4. Squirrel activity

If you’ve got squirrels (and you do), plan for it. Use baffles, distance, and squirrel-proof gear right from the start.

---

🧠 Final Thoughts

There’s a feeder for every bird—and every backyard. If you start with just one, go for a tube feeder or hopper feeder filled with black-oil sunflower seed, and build from there.

Whether you want to attract finches, cardinals, woodpeckers, or a whole colorful crew, choosing the right feeder will help turn your backyard into a bird paradise.